Greenland’s government has proposed removing Danish language instruction from grades 1 through 3, sparking concerns that the move could harm students’ future educational opportunities despite aims to strengthen native language skills. Business leaders warn the education system remains too dependent on Danish to reduce language teaching without a comprehensive long term plan.
Proposal Targets Early Language Learning
The Greenlandic government wants to eliminate Danish from the curriculum for the youngest students in grades 0 through 3. Officials argue this change will allow children to focus more deeply on the Greenlandic language during their formative years. The proposal forms part of a broader overhaul of Greenland’s primary education system.
Authorities claim students currently face too many subjects, creating a scattered and disjointed learning experience. Reducing the number of subjects should give students more time for deeper engagement with core skills, according to the government. The changes also aim to improve student wellbeing and support more rounded personal development.
Current System Requires Danish Proficiency
Danish instruction is currently mandatory across all ten grades of Greenlandic primary school. Many teachers in gymnasiums and vocational schools are Danish, and most teaching materials appear in Danish rather than Greenlandic. Students who wish to pursue higher education face significant Danish language requirements.
Greenland’s university, Ilisimatusarfik, offers 12 bachelor’s programs and five master’s programs. Because educational options remain limited on the island, roughly 30 percent of Greenlandic young people travel abroad to continue their studies. Most of these students head to Denmark, where Danish fluency becomes essential for academic success.
Business Community Raises Alarm
Christian Keldsen directs Grønlands Erhverv, the territory’s main business organization. He argues the education system depends far too heavily on Danish to justify reducing language instruction. Students need Danish skills beyond tenth grade to progress through gymnasiums and vocational training programs, he explains.
University education in Greenland or Denmark requires Danish proficiency. Eliminating Danish from early grades without a comprehensive replacement strategy could trap students in limited educational pathways. Keldsen emphasizes the need for planning that covers students from early childhood through their entire educational journey.
Long Term Educational Consequences
Students who fail to develop adequate Danish skills already struggle to advance in the school system. Some young people get stuck when they lack command of a second language because educational offerings remain scarce. The proposed changes could worsen this pattern if not carefully managed.
Few Alternatives for Higher Learning
Greenland Statistics data shows that more than half the population holds only primary school as their highest educational achievement. This compares sharply with Denmark, where just 10 percent stop their education after primary school. Limited access to advanced training contributes significantly to this educational gap.
Creating a fully Greenlandic language education system would require developing materials, training teachers, and building programs across all educational levels. No such comprehensive infrastructure currently exists. Without these foundations in place, removing Danish instruction could limit rather than expand opportunities for students.
Language Choice Requires Consistency
Keldsen points out that the specific language matters less than consistency throughout the education system. Schools could theoretically choose any language for instruction as long as they maintained that choice from primary school through university. However, Greenland has not established this kind of coherent pathway.
Students who speak only Greenlandic currently lack access to a complete educational system in their native language. This structural gap makes reducing Danish instruction risky without major systemic changes. The technical challenge involves not just language preference but building entire educational frameworks.
Earlier Language Learning Shows Benefits
Many Greenlandic schoolchildren now speak English with each other during breaks rather than Danish or Greenlandic. This shift appears in academic results, where 2024 data shows just over half of students earned top marks in oral English. Meanwhile, fewer than 30 percent achieved top marks in oral Danish.
Government Cites Developmental Readiness
The government proposal suggests introducing both Danish and English in fourth grade when children show greater developmental maturity. Officials cite international research indicating that strong native language skills support foreign language acquisition. This argument forms the basis for delaying second language instruction.
However, researchers at Ilisimatusarfik’s Institute for Learning dispute this narrow interpretation. They note that international research also demonstrates benefits when children learn multiple languages simultaneously. Exposure to more than one language can actually strengthen overall linguistic development rather than hinder it.
Global Trends Favor Early Instruction
Keldsen questions the logic of shielding young children from language learning when global demands for multilingual skills continue growing. Most education systems worldwide are moving toward earlier foreign language instruction, not delaying it. Denmark requires English from second grade, reflecting this international trend.
Children show greater capacity for language learning at younger ages according to established research. Starting language education early provides advantages that become harder to replicate later. The proposed delay runs counter to these well documented patterns of language acquisition.
Reduced Hours Raise Competitiveness Concerns
The government plan includes cutting instructional hours for the youngest students from 700 to 560 per school year. Danish students in equivalent grades receive at least 1,030 hours annually according to Denmark’s Ministry for Children and Education. This significant reduction adds to worries about educational quality.
Fewer Subjects and Less Time
Government officials argue that students currently juggle too many subjects, which fragments their learning experience. Concentrating on fewer topics should theoretically allow for better understanding and retention. The proposal aims to create more focused and coherent instruction rather than spreading attention too thin.
Critics worry this approach could leave Greenlandic students less prepared than peers elsewhere. Young people from Greenland will eventually compete for jobs and opportunities with others who received more comprehensive education. A less rigorous system might disadvantage them in these future competitions.
Economic Integration at Stake
The business community emphasizes that Greenlandic youth must remain competitive both domestically and internationally. Educational standards directly affect their ability to secure employment and build careers. A strong education system becomes essential for maintaining economic vitality and opportunity.
Keldsen expresses concern that fewer hours combined with a narrower curriculum could eventually create gaps in skills and knowledge. Students might find themselves unable to compete with those who followed different educational paths. This competitiveness question extends beyond language to overall educational rigor and breadth.
Political Response and Next Steps
The government has completed its consultation period on the proposal. Minister for Children, Youth and Education Nivi Olsen has not publicly addressed the criticisms raised by business leaders and researchers. The timeline for implementing any changes remains unclear.
Broader Reform Context
Eliminating early Danish instruction represents just one element of the proposed school reforms. The government seeks to fundamentally restructure how primary education operates in Greenland. These changes reflect long standing debates about balancing indigenous language preservation with practical educational needs.
The proposal touches on sensitive questions about Greenland’s relationship with Denmark and its path toward greater autonomy. Educational policy becomes intertwined with cultural identity and political sovereignty. Finding the right balance between these competing considerations presents ongoing challenges for policymakers.
Sources and References
The Danish Dream: What Language Do They Speak in Greenland? Find Out Now
The Danish Dream: Lower Interest in Danish Language Studies is Concerning
DR: Grønlands regering vil droppe danskundervisning til de yngste
Framtida
Folkeskolen
Iserasuaat
UVM
