A new review from Denmark’s Styrelsen for Patientsikkerhed finds that fertility clinics and gynecologists have for years failed to warn donor families about serious hereditary disease, and that the authority has almost no way to sanction them.
The review of the fertility sector was published this week. DR reports that several Danish clinics and gynecologists did not alert donor children and their mothers when a sperm donor was found to carry an inherited illness.
Under the rules, the mother and child must be warned immediately and offered genetic counseling. Birgitte Drewes, deputy director of Styrelsen for Patientsikkerhed, told DR that several clinics did not believe this was their task. She said the rules and the obligations are now clear to them.
Asked whether the clinics had been sanctioned, Drewes said the authority acts under the Danish Tissue Act, which contains very few administrative sanctions. She said the authority can file police reports, but that statutes of limitation also apply.
The review points to several other points of failure. In some cases, letters were sent to outdated email addresses, and clinics are not required to confirm that a warning actually arrived. Per Drewes, Danish law is satisfied once the women have been notified, with no requirement that they respond.
The authority also found cases where patient records were lost. Fertility clinics must store traceability data for 30 years, but contact details have disappeared after bankruptcies or changes of IT systems. Drewes said it is impossible to say what those data sets contained.
As a result, the authority does not know how many women still have not been told about a serious genetic risk in their child.
More than a decade under the radar
According to DR, the problems went unnoticed by Styrelsen for Patientsikkerhed for more than ten years. Drewes said there had been no signals suggesting the authority should examine the robustness of the notification chains. She said the vulnerability only became apparent during the review itself.
Drewes said she has full sympathy for families now asking whether they are affected. She said the authority will work to make the system more robust, and urged families to keep their contact details updated with their fertility clinic.
New legislation planned
The review has been underway since late last year, when DR uncovered the case of a sperm donor with a hidden cancer mutation. According to DR’s research, the man is the origin of more than 200 donor children worldwide. About 40 percent of the women treated with his sperm in Denmark were not reliably warned in time.
In earlier reporting on the review, DR noted that warnings were not delivered reliably or promptly when donors were later found to carry dangerous gene mutations.
Health Minister Ida Auken of the Social Democrats has said she wants stronger supervision of Danish fertility clinics and sperm banks. She plans to call health spokespeople to negotiations within the next month, aiming to send a bill for consultation before Christmas.






